Sunday, December 9, 2007

Wicca: Right or Wrong?


I'll give you three guesses as to whether or not this tract finds Wicca wrong. And if any of your guesses are no, you haven't been reading this blog very often, have you?

Published by the Good News Publishers and written by Christin Ditchfield (a Christian named Christin? What are the odds of that?), this tract aims to show the reader that Wicca is wrong. Does it succeed? No, it does not.

The tract starts by talking about Wicca in generalities. Sadly, I don't know enough about Wicca myself to say if these generalities are accurate or way off the mark. Christin actually makes Wicca sound attractive: "It promotes peace, harmony and healing," it "celebrates nature" and "empowers women" and "encourages creativity". Of course, Ms. Ditchfield is careful to begin this praise with the words: "Listen to anyone who practices the craft, and they'll tell you..."

At the bottom of the first page, Christin states that "Wicca doesn't work." the tract continues for a further four pages, but the subject of Wicca is never raised again. Instead, the remainder of the tract is devoted to pushing the Christian message. No proof is offered as to why Wicca doesn't work. Instead, Christin Ditchfield essentially says that her beliefs are the way things are, therefore any other system must be wrong.

This isn't the most arrogant thing I've ever read, but it's up there. It cracks the top fifty, for sure. I can't help but wonder why she chose the subject of Wicca, since she talks so little about it. She could have provided examples of Wicca not working, or of Christianity succeeding where Wicca 'fails', but alas she does not. This suggests she either hasn't done her homework, or she simply could not find any examples of Wicca not working. Either way, she makes the case for Wicca that much stronger.

The cover makes no sense. We have an image of a man on a tightrope, seemingly off-balance. Oh, and it looks as if the tightrope is stretching across a yellowy-red glowing expanse (hellfire, possibly?) Okay, I get what she's trying to say - people who practice Wicca are on a thin rope over HELL and could fall in at any moment. It's just that, with the subject of Wicca, could she not have chosen a cover image a bit more, I don't know, Wiccan? You know, a witch or a cauldron or something? Maybe a witch with a cauldron on that tightrope? I mean, come on. Even the Fellowship Tract League knows enough to tie the cover art in with what they are saying.

Seriously, Christin Ditchfield, what the fudge? If you're going to make a tract, don't just phone it in. If you'd provided a bit more evidence for your claims, you might have at least scored higher on the Level of Disturbing or Offensive Content category. You're not winning any souls here; all you are doing is preaching to the converted. I have to say you are very ironically named, not only because you are a Christian named Christin. Your name is also ironic because I'm about to crumple up this tract and ditch it in a field.

Likely to Convert - 0
Likely to Convince Anyone that Wicca is Wrong - 0
Artwork - 1
Ability to Hold Interest - 2
Unintentional Hilarity - 3
Level of Disturbing or Offensive Content - 4

5 comments:

Gary said...

I haven't read the tract; but it sounds as if you dedicated some time to doing so and for that I respect you.

However, as a practicing Wiccan, please do not dump the tract in a field... recycle it or use it to assist in starting a fire in your fireplace.

Thanks!

Timothy Carter said...

Yes, I try to read them through at least once so I can give an honest critique.

No, I will not actually throw this tract out into nature. Nature would throw it back at me.

Since you are a Wiccan, can you comment on the generalizations made in this tract?

Miran StormSeeker said...

I'm wiccan myself, and i find this tract to be really aggressive to us. i didnt read the tract, but from your description i can feel how the language was.

on the generlizations, its kind of true, not all of them though. i mean the generalization of making women powerful... its not true. our way says that everything in this universe was created in harmony, thus, women are as powerful as men IN THEIR WAY.
humans are not anything special in our way as the christian religion says. we believe that we are equal to the rocks, birds, trees, seas...etc, because everything in this universe was created to do its role in life.

Miran StormSeeker said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Miran StormSeeker said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.